Jump to content

Talk:Astronomy/Exoplanets: Difference between revisions

From Wiki - Scioly.org
mNo edit summary
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
Is there enough info to merit this being its own page, or should it just be part of the main [[Astronomy/Star and Planet Formation|Star and Planet Formation page]]? I guess just "Exoplanets" suggests that it's not just about the formation, but if there's not too much extra info, it might be good to just have it as part of the Planet Formation section of the aforementioned page. [[User:Eaststroudsburg13|Eaststroudsburg13]] ([[User talk:Eaststroudsburg13|talk]]) 07:28, 18 September 2015 (CDT)
Is there enough info to merit this being its own page, or should it just be part of the main [[Astronomy/Star and Planet Formation|Star and Planet Formation page]]? I guess just "Exoplanets" suggests that it's not just about the formation, but if there's not too much extra info, it might be good to just have it as part of the Planet Formation section of the aforementioned page. [[User:Eaststroudsburg13|Eaststroudsburg13]] ([[User talk:Eaststroudsburg13|talk]]) 07:28, 18 September 2015 (CDT)
          I just created this page because on the Astronomy rules, the topics are Star&Planet Formation and Exoplanets. I figured that since it is listed on the rules as a topic, it's good enough to have its own page, but I'm no wiki mod...[[User:Magikarpmastedr629|Magikarpmaster629]] ([[User talk:Magikarpmaster629|talk]]) 19:18, 18 September 2015
 
I just created this page because on the Astronomy rules, the topics are Star&Planet Formation and Exoplanets. I figured that since it is listed on the rules as a topic, it's good enough to have its own page, but I'm no wiki mod...[[User:Magikarpmastedr629|Magikarpmaster629]] ([[User talk:Magikarpmaster629|talk]]) 19:18, 18 September 2015
 
Based on the copy of the rules I have, it seems to be intended as "Star Formation and Exoplanets" instead of two separate topics, since they're both separate from "Stellar Evolution". I'm actually not sure why they changed the wording of this from last year, so we can keep this page separate for now and then link to this page as a "see also" from the Star and Planet Formation page. If this page ends up being a stub for an extended period of time, then we can just merge the two pages. [[User:Eaststroudsburg13|Eaststroudsburg13]] ([[User talk:Eaststroudsburg13|talk]]) 07:32, 19 September 2015 (CDT)


[[Category:Talk Pages]]
[[Category:Talk Pages]]

Revision as of 12:32, 19 September 2015

Is there enough info to merit this being its own page, or should it just be part of the main Star and Planet Formation page? I guess just "Exoplanets" suggests that it's not just about the formation, but if there's not too much extra info, it might be good to just have it as part of the Planet Formation section of the aforementioned page. Eaststroudsburg13 (talk) 07:28, 18 September 2015 (CDT)

I just created this page because on the Astronomy rules, the topics are Star&Planet Formation and Exoplanets. I figured that since it is listed on the rules as a topic, it's good enough to have its own page, but I'm no wiki mod...Magikarpmaster629 (talk) 19:18, 18 September 2015

Based on the copy of the rules I have, it seems to be intended as "Star Formation and Exoplanets" instead of two separate topics, since they're both separate from "Stellar Evolution". I'm actually not sure why they changed the wording of this from last year, so we can keep this page separate for now and then link to this page as a "see also" from the Star and Planet Formation page. If this page ends up being a stub for an extended period of time, then we can just merge the two pages. Eaststroudsburg13 (talk) 07:32, 19 September 2015 (CDT)