Page 1 of 1

Pulley to Inclined Plane Transfer - Height Requiremnet

Posted: January 11th, 2017, 3:45 pm
by MissionPossibleCoach
This year Pulley needs to move an object atleast 10 CM Vertical. For Inclined plane as well the same 10 CM vertical rule applies. My question is does each of these simple machine has to satisfy this separately or can they do it combined.

Lets say a pulley is pulling an object up the inclined plane and the object triggers the next action after it travels 10 cm vertical height along the inclined plane. Is this considered a scorable pulley to inclined plane transfer? Or should the pulley move the object up 20 cm (10 cm - Pulley + 10 cm- I/P) along the inclined plane for this to be a pulley to Inclined plane transfer?

Thanks

Re: Pulley to Inclined Plane Transfer - Height Requiremnet

Posted: January 11th, 2017, 6:11 pm
by torqueburner
MissionPossibleCoach wrote:This year Pulley needs to move an object atleast 10 CM Vertical. For Inclined plane as well the same 10 CM vertical rule applies. My question is does each of these simple machine has to satisfy this separately or can they do it combined.

Lets say a pulley is pulling an object up the inclined plane and the object triggers the next action after it travels 10 cm vertical height along the inclined plane. Is this considered a scorable pulley to inclined plane transfer? Or should the pulley move the object up 20 cm (10 cm - Pulley + 10 cm- I/P) along the inclined plane for this to be a pulley to Inclined plane transfer?

Thanks
I'd say that neither of the above would meet the rules. Rule 4.d.ii says that the pulley must "lift an object at least 10.0 cm vertically before the object initiates the next action. . .". Rule 3h indicates that the object lifted by the pulley cannot be the object moved along the inclined plane. So my interpretation is that the pulley must lift object A at least 10 cm vertically, after which object A initiates an action that lifts object B at least 10 cm vertically along the inclined plane. In other words, each machine needs to satisfy its requirements before initiating the next action/machine, which must satisfy its own requirements.

Re: Pulley to Inclined Plane Transfer - Height Requiremnet

Posted: January 11th, 2017, 7:19 pm
by MissionPossibleCoach
That was my second doubt about it which you already clarified.

Thanks

Re: Pulley to Inclined Plane Transfer - Height Requiremnet

Posted: January 30th, 2017, 4:32 pm
by mderoller
torqueburner wrote:
MissionPossibleCoach wrote:This year Pulley needs to move an object atleast 10 CM Vertical. For Inclined plane as well the same 10 CM vertical rule applies. My question is does each of these simple machine has to satisfy this separately or can they do it combined.

Lets say a pulley is pulling an object up the inclined plane and the object triggers the next action after it travels 10 cm vertical height along the inclined plane. Is this considered a scorable pulley to inclined plane transfer? Or should the pulley move the object up 20 cm (10 cm - Pulley + 10 cm- I/P) along the inclined plane for this to be a pulley to Inclined plane transfer?

Thanks
I'd say that neither of the above would meet the rules. Rule 4.d.ii says that the pulley must "lift an object at least 10.0 cm vertically before the object initiates the next action. . .". Rule 3h indicates that the object lifted by the pulley cannot be the object moved along the inclined plane. So my interpretation is that the pulley must lift object A at least 10 cm vertically, after which object A initiates an action that lifts object B at least 10 cm vertically along the inclined plane. In other words, each machine needs to satisfy its requirements before initiating the next action/machine, which must satisfy its own requirements.
That's my interpretation as well.