Water Quality B/C

User avatar
silentsage
Member
Member
Posts: 88
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 10:09 am
Division: C
State: PA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by silentsage »

ptkid wrote:
lolliexdd wrote:I hope this hasn't been answered yet..

We've been having problems building a salinometer like the one they recommended we make, with a straw and clay. Every day that we test any of our salinometers (we've used 3 types of clay already) in tap water, they all float to a different line than the day before. We've even used deionized water instead of tap water to calibrate it, but we still have the same problem. Do any of you know how to fix this?
Okay, so when I tried making that one it just doesn't work. The soinc.org people are just wrong. A simple straw and clay model cannot be that accurate and can easily break. You need to think more sophisticated like how you can make it more accurate. Experiment to get a good salinometer.


And they basically are the same (deionized and distilled water).
I agree, the soinc one is innacurate, but you can firm the clay by lightly coating it in superglue. I've tried to find how to build and electronic one (they are legal), but no luck, anyone else?
Road Scholar seems to depress everyone on my team who does it, but it's my favorite event...
I <3 DQIX and Squirtle
2013 RS National Champ
ptkid
Member
Member
Posts: 246
Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2011 6:54 am
Division: Grad
State: TX
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by ptkid »

silentsage wrote:
ptkid wrote:
lolliexdd wrote:I hope this hasn't been answered yet..

We've been having problems building a salinometer like the one they recommended we make, with a straw and clay. Every day that we test any of our salinometers (we've used 3 types of clay already) in tap water, they all float to a different line than the day before. We've even used deionized water instead of tap water to calibrate it, but we still have the same problem. Do any of you know how to fix this?
Okay, so when I tried making that one it just doesn't work. The soinc.org people are just wrong. A simple straw and clay model cannot be that accurate and can easily break. You need to think more sophisticated like how you can make it more accurate. Experiment to get a good salinometer.


And they basically are the same (deionized and distilled water).
I agree, the soinc one is innacurate, but you can firm the clay by lightly coating it in superglue. I've tried to find how to build and electronic one (they are legal), but no luck, anyone else?
same. I had no luck. I found out what I was doing was totally wrong so I just made the straw one more sophisticated.
Seven Lakes High School '16
Previous National Champion in Green Generation and National Medalist in CJAP, Disease Detectives, Entomology, & Water Quality
User avatar
rtunnel97
Member
Member
Posts: 39
Joined: Thu Feb 02, 2012 11:23 am
Division: C
State: NY
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by rtunnel97 »

I made one a step up from the simple clay and straw, but still it isn't that accurate, i just know it :(
“If you like nerds, raise your hand. If you don't, raise your standards.”
cngu23
Member
Member
Posts: 248
Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2011 4:57 pm
Division: C
State: MD
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by cngu23 »

rtunnel97 wrote:I made one a step up from the simple clay and straw, but still it isn't that accurate, i just know it :(
Since you get the point for measuring to the nearest percent, should line spacings of around 2.5% be enough for a rough estimate?
Marriotts Ridge 11-
Walter Johnson 09-11

13 MD Regional/State
Material S (2/-) TPS (-/2)
12 MD Regional/State
Remote S(2/6) Water Q(2/4) Optics (-/5)
11 MD Regional
Remote S(2) Eco(2) D Planet(3)
User avatar
2win
Member
Member
Posts: 553
Joined: Tue Mar 03, 2009 6:07 pm
Division: C
State: TX
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by 2win »

cngu23 wrote:
rtunnel97 wrote:I made one a step up from the simple clay and straw, but still it isn't that accurate, i just know it :(
Since you get the point for measuring to the nearest percent, should line spacings of around 2.5% be enough for a rough estimate?
I thought I depended on the proctor, but I think that's good enough, since some people are doing 3% or more. 1% is a butt to mark off...
k-tx. retiring from scioly.
User avatar
PacificGoldenPlover
Exalted Member
Exalted Member
Posts: 519
Joined: Sun Apr 10, 2011 6:51 pm
Division: Grad
State: CA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 4 times

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by PacificGoldenPlover »

Really? For our salinometer it was fairly easy (the entire range was about 1.5 inches)
Life List: n. A list of bird species definitively seen by a birdwatcher.
PacificGoldenPlover's Life List : 319
Most recent lifer: Red-throated Loon

2014 (Mira Loma/Troy/Regionals/States/Nationals)
Dynamic Planet (2/2/1/1/1)
Designer Genes (1/4/1/13 (???)/13 (figures)
Water Quality (1/1/3/1/3)
cngu23
Member
Member
Posts: 248
Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2011 4:57 pm
Division: C
State: MD
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by cngu23 »

PacificGoldenPlover wrote:Really? For our salinometer it was fairly easy (the entire range was about 1.5 inches)
Couldn't get something wide enough to create a large enough different spacing, so I marked it each 2.5%. Spacings are 3mm apart, so its about 1mm per percent concentration. Not the best, but for a maximum of 5% of the competition result, I feel like it would be better to spend more time studying for the written section.
Marriotts Ridge 11-
Walter Johnson 09-11

13 MD Regional/State
Material S (2/-) TPS (-/2)
12 MD Regional/State
Remote S(2/6) Water Q(2/4) Optics (-/5)
11 MD Regional
Remote S(2) Eco(2) D Planet(3)
User avatar
PacificGoldenPlover
Exalted Member
Exalted Member
Posts: 519
Joined: Sun Apr 10, 2011 6:51 pm
Division: Grad
State: CA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 4 times

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by PacificGoldenPlover »

Is it against the spirit of the rules to bring in multiple salinometers?
Life List: n. A list of bird species definitively seen by a birdwatcher.
PacificGoldenPlover's Life List : 319
Most recent lifer: Red-throated Loon

2014 (Mira Loma/Troy/Regionals/States/Nationals)
Dynamic Planet (2/2/1/1/1)
Designer Genes (1/4/1/13 (???)/13 (figures)
Water Quality (1/1/3/1/3)
cngu23
Member
Member
Posts: 248
Joined: Sat Mar 12, 2011 4:57 pm
Division: C
State: MD
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 1 time

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by cngu23 »

PacificGoldenPlover wrote:Is it against the spirit of the rules to bring in multiple salinometers?
Since my salinometers are not that accurate, and marked 2.5%, I am using 2 salinometers to confirm my measurements.
Marriotts Ridge 11-
Walter Johnson 09-11

13 MD Regional/State
Material S (2/-) TPS (-/2)
12 MD Regional/State
Remote S(2/6) Water Q(2/4) Optics (-/5)
11 MD Regional
Remote S(2) Eco(2) D Planet(3)
User avatar
silentsage
Member
Member
Posts: 88
Joined: Thu Dec 22, 2011 10:09 am
Division: C
State: PA
Has thanked: 0
Been thanked: 0

Re: Water Quality B/C

Post by silentsage »

cngu23 wrote:
PacificGoldenPlover wrote:Is it against the spirit of the rules to bring in multiple salinometers?
Since my salinometers are not that accurate, and marked 2.5%, I am using 2 salinometers to confirm my measurements.
I don't know anything about multiple salinometers, but I made solutions for every even % and filled in the odds. Does anyone think that proctors are scared to make a solution below 3% or above 8%? I've never encountered any higher.
Road Scholar seems to depress everyone on my team who does it, but it's my favorite event...
I <3 DQIX and Squirtle
2013 RS National Champ

Return to “2012 Study Events”