Page 28 of 28

Re: Disease Detective B/C

Posted: Fri Aug 17, 2012 1:45 pm
by Cedavis6
They'll have a new forum about it up around schooltime.

Re: Disease Detective B/C

Posted: Fri Aug 17, 2012 6:14 pm
by Luo
Equality 7-2521 wrote:Does anyone know of any diseases that we might need to know about for this? (i'm new...)
Disease Detectives (at least, for the majority of tests you'll likely encounter) focuses more on the epidemiology process rather than on knowledge of specific diseases. If you're new to the event, I would recommend checking out the training guide on soinc.org: http://soinc.org/sites/default/files/20 ... ANDOUT.pdf. It contains a lot of helpful information to start you out. Good luck! :)

Re: Disease Detective B/C

Posted: Sat Aug 18, 2012 8:57 pm
by Equality 7-2521
Thanks, Luo!

Another question:
The epidemiological process is based on scientific inquiry.
Experimental design is an event that uses scientific inquiry to design experiments.
However, epidemiology (as far as I understand it so far) cannot be run as an experiment- you can't always control and assign all variables.

So how does this all relate?

Re: Disease Detective B/C

Posted: Sun Aug 19, 2012 9:13 am
by Luo
Equality 7-2521 wrote:Thanks, Luo!

Another question:
The epidemiological process is based on scientific inquiry.
Experimental design is an event that uses scientific inquiry to design experiments.
However, epidemiology (as far as I understand it so far) cannot be run as an experiment- you can't always control and assign all variables.

So how does this all relate?
Ideally, epidemiologists would be able to use experiments. However, this would be unethical in most cases - for example, you couldn't willfully expose people to a suspected contaminated food to see if they contract an illness. Thus, epidemiologists are usually limited to using observational studies (cohort, case control, cross-sectional, etc.) and making only inferences about causation. These inferences can be based in part on risk ratios, odds ratios, and several other statistics commonly used by epidemiologists. You'll often have confounding variables, so problem-solving will be required to make the strongest inference possible about the cause/source of a given disease. Though this most likely transcends the realm of the Disease Detectives event, such problem-solving is based on a robust working knowledge of the dynamics of the specific disease and of human-geographical/environmental patterns in the given area.

To answer your question, scientific inquiry can go beyond just experimentation - into the realm of rigorous observational studies and inference as well. This type of scientific inquiry is what must be applied in Disease Detectives. Hope this helps!