Page 3 of 4

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: March 18th, 2017, 11:58 pm
by SOPomo
Haven't seen Bay Area regional results but I assume Hopkins/Horner were some version of 1-2 in B.

Santa Clara regional today finished Kennedy, Miller, Challenger, Basis in B.

Now on to the real showdown, Churchill and Kennedy for only one national spot for some reason.

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: March 19th, 2017, 7:41 am
by EastStroudsburg13
SOPomo wrote:Now on to the real showdown, Churchill and Kennedy for only one national spot for some reason.
The reason is simple: maximum of 2 teams per state per division. This is to ensure that nationals has an even distribution of teams from across the country. It's important to note that nationals is meant to be the best teams from each state in the country, not the best teams overall in the country.

Now, debating that reasoning is a completely different story. It's definitely a debatable point, as evidenced by the numerous threads that have appeared recently regarding this issue. However, there is no real simple solution to this, unfortunately. Perhaps eventually a 3-team threshold will be introduced, but that still seems to be a ways off.

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: March 19th, 2017, 12:23 pm
by Dohnnovan
SOPomo wrote:Haven't seen Bay Area regional results but I assume Hopkins/Horner were some version of 1-2 in B.

Santa Clara regional today finished Kennedy, Miller, Challenger, Basis in B.

Now on to the real showdown, Churchill and Kennedy for only one national spot for some reason.
I believe it was Kennedy, Miller, Challenger, and chaboya. http://www.santaclarascioly.com/2015%20 ... SCORES.pdf

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: March 19th, 2017, 12:26 pm
by Dohnnovan
Dohnnovan wrote:
SOPomo wrote:Haven't seen Bay Area regional results but I assume Hopkins/Horner were some version of 1-2 in B.

Santa Clara regional today finished Kennedy, Miller, Challenger, Basis in B.

Now on to the real showdown, Churchill and Kennedy for only one national spot for some reason.
I believe it was Kennedy, Miller, Challenger, and chaboya. http://www.santaclarascioly.com/2015%20 ... SCORES.pdf
I just realized those were scores from 2015

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: March 19th, 2017, 1:05 pm
by MIScioly
EastStroudsburg13 wrote:
SOPomo wrote:Now on to the real showdown, Churchill and Kennedy for only one national spot for some reason.
The reason is simple: maximum of 2 teams per state per division. This is to ensure that nationals has an even distribution of teams from across the country. It's important to note that nationals is meant to be the best teams from each state in the country, not the best teams overall in the country.

Now, debating that reasoning is a completely different story. It's definitely a debatable point, as evidenced by the numerous threads that have appeared recently regarding this issue. However, there is no real simple solution to this, unfortunately. Perhaps eventually a 3-team threshold will be introduced, but that still seems to be a ways off.
I agree. Nationals is the best teams from each state. If you want to go to nationals, you have to be the best in your state (or one of the top 2). I think a 3-team threshold would be fair to the top states like California, New York, Michigan etc. but I think that would have to be the limit.

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: April 1st, 2017, 12:46 pm
by windu34
Live stream?

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: April 1st, 2017, 4:36 pm
by SOPomo
Won't be doing a live stream, but I can semi do uodates.

Early buzz is that it's pretty darn close between Churchill and Kennedy, and one bad event could decide it again. Mira Loma starting to feel the heat from Palo Alton and Mountain View but may not finish as close as DivB.

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: April 1st, 2017, 5:37 pm
by SOPomo
With four events left, Churchill has only missed one medal and Kennedy three. It's looking like Churchill right now.

Mira Loma is sweeping C, but 9 left there.

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: April 1st, 2017, 6:07 pm
by Dohnnovan
California B Division Final Results:
1. Winston Churchill Middle School - Qualifies for the 2017 National Tournament
2. Kennedy Middle School
3. Miller Middle School

California C Division Final Results:
1. Mira Loma High School - Qualifies for the 2017 National Tournament
2. Mountain View High School
3. Palo Alto High School

Looks like Churchill did it again, I saw that coming. What i didn't see, was Miller taking 3rd in B division.

Re: Northern California 2017

Posted: April 2nd, 2017, 2:53 pm
by Entomology
Dohnnovan wrote:California B Division Final Results:
1. Winston Churchill Middle School - Qualifies for the 2017 National Tournament
2. Kennedy Middle School
3. Miller Middle School

California C Division Final Results:
1. Mira Loma High School - Qualifies for the 2017 National Tournament
2. Mountain View High School
3. Palo Alto High School

Looks like Churchill did it again, I saw that coming. What i didn't see, was Miller taking 3rd in B division.
Man...every single year Kennedy starts off super strong and every single year Churchill pulls through at states. Regardless, it's insanely impressive that either team only missed medaling in a couple of events.