Page 20 of 21
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: May 21st, 2018, 9:31 pm
by syo_astro
Ten086 wrote:Thanks for your hard work this year! Any chance you could leak the DSO list for next year too?
For real tho, the nats test had a lot more DSO questions than we were expecting :O I was also surprised to see that imaging analysis stuff, I thought everyone was saying it's never really showed up on a test before rip. My partner and I are really happy with our placement and hopefully we'll do astro together again next year :v!
Just for reference: I didn't write the test...we have a large enough group of volunteers anyway that while the sections and format may be somewhat "standard", the exact content should hopefully stay exciting and varied for years to come

.
A few notes:
DSOs are typically the first section of tests, and they are VERY important (thus getting a lot of coverage). Definitely worth studying as they even help you learn the event. Also, you're going to have to think of a more creative way of finding the DSOs than that:P.
The image analysis...I did say "it has been used on some"...DS9 is still relevant, we're just trying to think of accessible activities. Imaging, spectra, etc are always important anyway.
Finally, good job!
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: May 25th, 2018, 7:35 pm
by PM2017
syo_astro wrote:
The image analysis...I did say "it has been used on some"...DS9 is still relevant, we're just trying to think of accessible activities. Imaging, spectra, etc are always important anyway.
Can you give us some examples of DS9 related questions?
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: May 26th, 2018, 11:46 am
by syo_astro
PM2017 wrote:Can you give us some examples of DS9 related questions?
My rambling here probably won't help much, I'm still figuring out ways to use it on a test (it is a professional tool, though, which is cool). I thought there were past nationals exams that used DS9 (nats exams should be all over the test exchange, soinc.org, etc). If you want some very general ideas, I think this year's test had an X ray spectrum on it (made by using DS9), and it's often useful for "image analysis" (counting pixels, color schemes, stacking multi wavelength images).
Royalreter wrote:...I saw the above linked post and was wondering if you had access to the 2010 or 2011 rules...[some questions about how to study for this topic]
This quote came from someone asking me about studying without the rules / finding old rules. Answering here because it's relevant to many, and I might get PM'd about that a bunch. I do not have the 2010 rules and am not allowed to share them in any case. See
viewtopic.php?f=4&t=11993 for a detailed conversation about this.
Regarding "galaxies topics" being broad, I believe I made no mistake in stating "Galaxies" (see my Edit in
this post). Besides, isn't "stellar evolution" also a broad topic? People are maybe annoyed at my repetitions, but understand that I prefer to not "overexplain" general questions. Anyway, don't be afraid of "useless" studying...if you study over the summer, it'll probably be useful.
As for topics to study, why not discuss here if everyone is excited;)? If you want a starting point, where do you start for previous years? Lastly, if you do SSSS, I'll try to help answer questions after people get going. I think that'll be more manageable for me, and, as I sometimes say, specific questions -> specific answers (unless you all just talk to each other...that works too).
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: July 28th, 2018, 8:23 am
by pb5754
I don't know if this has been mentioned anywhere, but are we allowed to use a wireless mouse? Just wondering...
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: July 28th, 2018, 1:53 pm
by Adi1008
pb5754[] wrote:I don't know if this has been mentioned anywhere, but are we allowed to use a wireless mouse? Just wondering...
I used a wireless mouse and didn't run into any complaints from event supervisors.
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: July 28th, 2018, 1:57 pm
by pb5754
Adi1008 wrote:pb5754[] wrote:I don't know if this has been mentioned anywhere, but are we allowed to use a wireless mouse? Just wondering...
I used a wireless mouse and didn't run into any complaints from event supervisors.
OK Thanks!
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: July 28th, 2018, 4:11 pm
by syo_astro
pb5754[] wrote:Adi1008 wrote:pb5754[] wrote:I don't know if this has been mentioned anywhere, but are we allowed to use a wireless mouse? Just wondering...
I used a wireless mouse and didn't run into any complaints from event supervisors.
OK Thanks!
Something something this forum is not the place for official clarifications? That said, this is a pretty niche question that probably most wouldn't think about...so send in an FAQ? I guess you could argue an annoyed ES with the flash drive FAQ, but it's better to ask just in case.
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: July 28th, 2018, 4:22 pm
by pb5754
syo_astro wrote:pb5754[] wrote:Adi1008 wrote:
I used a wireless mouse and didn't run into any complaints from event supervisors.
OK Thanks!
Something something this forum is not the place for official clarifications? That said, this is a pretty niche question that probably most wouldn't think about...so send in an FAQ? I guess you could argue an annoyed ES with the flash drive FAQ, but it's better to ask just in case.
Oh yeah lol I forgot about the FAQs. I guess I'll send one in.
But would they actually check for FAQs after the season is over though?
EDIT: According to the SOINC FAQ page (
https://www.soinc.org/events/frequently-asked-questions):
SOINC wrote:Clarifications & FAQs open October 1 and close May 1.
So I guess I'll (probably) have to wait until October 1st...

Re: Astronomy C
Posted: August 3rd, 2018, 8:22 am
by PM2017
In regards to the conversation above, I've seen teams bring things like clipbaords, or desk extensions to place all their items. My partner was telling me she even saw one of these at state.
I'm not sure about the legality of these items, so since we are on this topic we might as well discuss these as well.
Re: Astronomy C
Posted: August 3rd, 2018, 10:59 am
by Unome
PM2017 wrote:In regards to the conversation above, I've seen teams bring things like clipbaords, or desk extensions to place all their items. My partner was telling me she even saw one of these at state.
I'm not sure about the legality of these items, so since we are on this topic we might as well discuss these as well.
I would say it's up to the event supervisor. Personally, I would not allow either of those. My limits on things outside of the rules basically comes down to pencils (and lead), erasers, and pencil sharpeners.