mason high school breaks the scale and does better than 1st
Everyone else (1-59)
Troy (60)
I honestly don't think anyone can beat this prediction.
Re: Unofficial Rankings C
Posted: May 16th, 2019, 6:29 am
by kate!
BennyTheJett wrote:
TheSquaad wrote:
pb5754[] wrote:I liked kate!'s idea so I added ranges as well:
1. Troy (1-3
2. Mason (1-4)
3. Solon (1-4)
4. Acton-Boxborough (3-7)
5. Mounds View (4-9)
6. Seven Lakes (5-9)
7. WW-P South (6-13)
8. Harriton (6-11)
9. Columbia (7-12)
10. Boca Raton (8-12)
11. Stevenson (8-13)
12. Mira Loma (9-14)
13. New Trier (10-15)
14. Rustin (Corteva (DuPont) Enterprise Award Winner) (13-16)
15. Enloe (12-18)
16. Northville (14-19)
17. Ward Melville (16-20)
18. Brookwood (17-21)
19. TJHSST (18-24)
20. Pembroke (17-23)
21. NCSSM (18-23)
22. Clark (19-24)
23. Chattahoochee (19-23)
24. Bothell (21-28)
25. Madison West (21-28)
What an awful predict. You didn’t even close the parentheses around Troy’s range.
All mechanics aside, this seems very feasible.
Edit: You may have fixed it. But it is forever documented in my reply quote.
Madison is strong this year. I put in the 17-22 range. Kate is also sleeping on Pioneer (16-23). I like where you put Bothell. I think Rustin might be a bit lower than Kate's prediction. I'd also put Boca ahead of Columbia. Other than that, well done.
I personally do not think Pioneer is strong enough to get in the top 20, they're a brand new nationals team and they haven't really shown anything spectacular. However I think they're able to get top 25, so I'm not sure why pb didn't put them there. Also I again would like to bring this up- why should Boca be higher than Columbia? Are we really basing this on one single invitational? Yes, Boca had an outstanding performance there, but Columbia also had an outstanding performance at states and Columbia is ranked higher historically than Boca. Boca has hardly ever made top 15 let alone top 10 and I sincerely doubt that they'll be able to beat Columbia.
Re: Unofficial Rankings C
Posted: May 16th, 2019, 6:59 am
by EastStroudsburg13
kate! wrote:
BennyTheJett wrote:
TheSquaad wrote:
What an awful predict. You didn’t even close the parentheses around Troy’s range.
All mechanics aside, this seems very feasible.
Edit: You may have fixed it. But it is forever documented in my reply quote.
Madison is strong this year. I put in the 17-22 range. Kate is also sleeping on Pioneer (16-23). I like where you put Bothell. I think Rustin might be a bit lower than Kate's prediction. I'd also put Boca ahead of Columbia. Other than that, well done.
I personally do not think Pioneer is strong enough to get in the top 20, they're a brand new nationals team and they haven't really shown anything spectacular. However I think they're able to get top 25, so I'm not sure why pb didn't put them there. Also I again would like to bring this up- why should Boca be higher than Columbia? Are we really basing this on one single invitational? Yes, Boca had an outstanding performance there, but Columbia also had an outstanding performance at states and Columbia is ranked higher historically than Boca. Boca has hardly ever made top 15 let alone top 10 and I sincerely doubt that they'll be able to beat Columbia.
This year's Boca team compares favorably to the team that placed 12th in 2017. Boca's other years of not making the top 15 do not really apply this year, as none of those years are as similar to this year as 2017 is.
Re: Unofficial Rankings C
Posted: May 16th, 2019, 10:17 am
by pb5754
kate! wrote:However I think they're able to get top 25, so I'm not sure why pb didn't put them there.
nah i just forgot that they (and Carmel) existed lol oops
Re: Unofficial Rankings C
Posted: May 16th, 2019, 6:54 pm
by lumosityfan
I'm going to suck at these but here goes...
1. Troy
2. Solon
3. Mason
4. Seven Lakes
5. Acton-Boxborough
6. Boca Raton
7. Columbia
8. Mounds View
9. Harriton
10. WWP South
11. New Trier
12. Stevenson
13. Mira Loma
14. Enloe
15. Northville
16. Rustin
17. Carmel
18. Ward Melville
19. Pioneer
20. Brookwood
lumosityfan wrote:I'm going to suck at these but here goes...
1. Troy
2. Solon
3. Mason
4. Seven Lakes
5. Acton-Boxborough
6. Boca Raton
7. Columbia
8. Mounds View
9. Harriton
10. WWP South
11. New Trier
12. Stevenson
13. Mira Loma
14. Enloe
15. Northville
16. Rustin
17. Carmel
18. Ward Melville
19. Pioneer
20. Brookwood
Why is Carmel so high? I sincerely doubt they'll be able to beat Ward Melville, let alone make top 20.
Re: Unofficial Rankings C
Posted: May 16th, 2019, 8:11 pm
by lumosityfan
kate! wrote:
lumosityfan wrote:I'm going to suck at these but here goes...
1. Troy
2. Solon
3. Mason
4. Seven Lakes
5. Acton-Boxborough
6. Boca Raton
7. Columbia
8. Mounds View
9. Harriton
10. WWP South
11. New Trier
12. Stevenson
13. Mira Loma
14. Enloe
15. Northville
16. Rustin
17. Carmel
18. Ward Melville
19. Pioneer
20. Brookwood
Why is Carmel so high? I sincerely doubt they'll be able to beat Ward Melville, let alone make top 20.
Well last year Carmel made Top 20 and they improved their state score plus while Ward's been doing well this year, I'd like to take into account more schools surging and having a good year than the normal excellence Ward brings. That being said, I was thinking about whether to flip the two.
Re: Unofficial Rankings C
Posted: May 16th, 2019, 8:31 pm
by kate!
lumosityfan wrote:
kate! wrote:
lumosityfan wrote:I'm going to suck at these but here goes...
1. Troy
2. Solon
3. Mason
4. Seven Lakes
5. Acton-Boxborough
6. Boca Raton
7. Columbia
8. Mounds View
9. Harriton
10. WWP South
11. New Trier
12. Stevenson
13. Mira Loma
14. Enloe
15. Northville
16. Rustin
17. Carmel
18. Ward Melville
19. Pioneer
20. Brookwood
Why is Carmel so high? I sincerely doubt they'll be able to beat Ward Melville, let alone make top 20.
Well last year Carmel made Top 20 and they improved their state score plus while Ward's been doing well this year, I'd like to take into account more schools surging and having a good year than the normal excellence Ward brings. That being said, I was thinking about whether to flip the two.
I mean I do think Carmel has significant potential and what I said before probably won't be true now that I'm looking at results but I still think Ward Melville can beat them if they fix the bombed events at states.