pumptato-cat wrote: ↑June 30th, 2023, 9:12 am
Hey! Not MorningCoffee but here's my take on it.
I think that the Discord has replaced the forums for everything. Instead of being a replacement for the forums, I agree with MorningCoffee about having things happen on "strictly forums." I like the superlative idea. I'm probably going to make a bad suggestion here, but maybe remove the "events" channel and move event discussion to here? There's a lot of great info in the Discord but it's just a lot easier to find info when it's archived in the forums.
Yeah, I think we should have more stuff happen strictly on the forums too! I think some steps we can take are better publicizing incentives for contributing (like collecting those fancy stars on your profile), as well as holding some events and stuff on the forums.
Unfortunately, I don't think removing the #events channel would really have the effect you'd hope. People would just end up talking about events in other channels like #scioly instead of being directed to the forums. I think one of the big problems is that people want quick and easy answers, which is why they turn to a platform like Discord (which is real-time) instead of a forum where it might take a bit to get an answer.
A lot of people are also used to a certain other Science Olympiad server with individual channels for each event, and they often assume we operate the same way and get confused by the fact that we have one general #events channel. People want what they want, and I think it's better to redirect by incentivizing forums use rather than dissuading people from using the Discord (since the latter probably wouldn't accomplish much).
I sometimes wish we could go back to a time where we only relied on the forums, but having a mix of traditional forums and a Discord server is the best way forward (in my opinion). I know for a fact that there's plenty of people who found out about the site
because of the Discord, and I worry that if we had never made it then people just wouldn't use the site at all.
There's a lot of "coulda woulda shoulda" in this conversation, but whatever. I'd just like to envision a world where people take advantage of every section of the site, not just the Discord or Wiki.